80+ Google Reviews for the  Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin

Why Did I Receive an NYPD Disqualification?

An NYPD candidate can be disqualified from a law enforcement position for a number of reasons, including:

Psychological issues: Anxiety, depression, anger, poor judgment, poor impulse control, poor stress tolerance, poor interpersonal skills and substance misuse, just to name a few.

School records: Candidates can also be disqualified for having an Individual Education Plan (IEP) or having taken ADHD medicine while in school.

Other factors: Racial bias, poor presentation, immaturity and failure to adjust to adulthood are other factors that can lead to a candidate receiving a disqualification.

The NYPD’s psychological exam is designed to assess a candidate’s emotional and psychological fitness for law enforcement. The exam includes both a written test and oral interview. The written test consists of questionnaires, symptom inventories, and personality inventory measures, while the oral interview is a one-on-one evaluation with a psychologist.

If you have been disqualified, you can appeal the decision by hiring an independent psychologist to assess you. You may also want to explain that what happened while you were in school is not your current state or condition. In any event, you should take some type of action in order to avoid having the disqualification become final, as this may affect your ability to get any other civil service jobs in the future.

Our firm is led by a retired NYPD Captain with experience in the NYPD Legal Bureau. We have helped numerous candidates successfully appeal their disqualifications over the past 22 years, and we understand the complexities of the process better than anyone.

In addition to offering the industry standards associated with appealing an NYPD Psychological Disqualification, at the Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin, Candidates are offered the option to Reply to their NYPD Disqualification, as we believe Replies can be an effective tool when a Candidate Receives a Notice of Proposed Disqualification (NOPD).

Your Reply will not only list point-by-point responses to the NYPD’s factual and expert assertions, but will also reassert your expert’s findings and offer legal arguments that challenge the sufficiency and validity of the NYPD’s evidence and findings.

Kevin and his experienced legal team have found Replies to be a very powerful tool, as they are useful for rebutting new arguments, clarifying facts and protecting the records, which can often change the outcome of a Candidate’s disqualification.

Tune in to Kevin’s New York civil service law attorney podcast for further tips, guidance and information about the NYPD Hiring Process. And don’t forget to subscribe and leave a review if you find his episodes helpful.  Remember, stay focused, stay prepared and never give up on your dreams.

Should You Hire an NYPD Disqualification Appeals Attorney

If you failed your NYPD Psychological Evaluation or have been disqualified for any reason and would like to schedule a free consultation, feel free to contact Kevin Sheerin at (631) 239-5825.

Email: kevin@sheerinlaw.com

Website: www.sheerinlaw.com

Blog: civilservice.sheerinlaw.com

Podcast: www.newyorkcivilservicelawattorneypodcast.com

-Why Did I Receive an NYPD Disqualification?

80+ Five-Star Google Reviews for the Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin

Nassau County Civil Service Disqualification Appeals…

What You Need to Know — And How Sheerin Law Can Help

If you have received a Notice of Disqualification from the Nassau County Civil Service Commission, you have the right to appeal — but the process is strict, time-sensitive, and highly technical.

Below is a clear summary of the Commission’s official appeal rules, followed by why experienced legal representation can make a critical difference in the outcome of your case.

Official Guidelines –

1. You Have the Right to Appeal – Under Nassau County Civil Service Commission rules, every disqualified applicant has the right to challenge the decision.

You may:
● Represent yourself, or
● Retain an attorney to submit the appeal on your behalf
Only the applicant or their authorized attorney may initiate the appeal.

2. Strict 30-Day Deadline:

Your appeal must be postmarked within 30 days of the date listed on your disqualification notice.
● Late appeals will not be considered.
● Failure to respond is treated as a waiver of your right to challenge the decision.
● Extensions are granted only for “good cause.”
Missing this deadline permanently ends your opportunity to challenge the disqualification.

3. Appeals Must Be Mailed — Not Emailed:

The Commission requires:
● Hard copy submission
● Mailed to the address listed in your notice
● Complete and legible documentation
Email submissions will not be accepted or reviewed. This is an important procedural trap. Improper submission can result in automatic rejection.

4. Five-Page Limit:

Your written appeal must:
● Be no longer than five (5) pages
● Use 12-point font
● Be concise and fact-focused
● Address only issues directly related to your disqualification. This means you have limited space to make a persuasive legal and factual argument. Every
sentence must count.

5. Supporting Documentation Rules:

You must include:
● All supporting documentation with your initial mailing
● Up to three (3) reference letters
● Reference letters addressing:
○ Character
○ Qualifications
○ Experience
○ Specific disqualification issues
Separate or late submissions are not accepted.

6. The Commission Can Raise New Issues:

Even after you file your appeal, the Commission reserves the right to assert additional grounds for disqualification if new information arises during review. This makes strategic drafting critical — your appeal must anticipate potential issues.

Why Hiring an Attorney Matters – 

Need Legal Help for NYPD Psychological Disqualification Appeal?

While the rules allow self-representation, Nassau County appeals are not simply “explanations.” They are structured legal challenges that must:

● Address the specific grounds cited
● Correct factual misunderstandings
● Present mitigating evidence effectively
● Frame your suitability in terms of present fitness
● Avoid triggering additional concerns
● Stay within strict formatting and procedural rules. A poorly drafted five-page appeal can permanently harm your chances.

An experienced civil service attorney understands how to:

● Analyze the legal basis for disqualification
● Organize evidence strategically
● Draft persuasive submissions within the five-page limit
● Prepare effective reference letters
● Anticipate additional grounds the Commission may assert
● Protect your long-term eligibility

Why Sheerin Law?

For more than 22 years, Sheerin Law has represented civil service candidates in disqualification appeals across the New York metropolitan area.

We understand:
● Psychological disqualifications
● Medical disqualifications
● Background/character concerns
● Prior employment issues
● Past arrests or youthful mistakes
● Credit history concerns
● Integrity allegations

We know how to frame your case around present suitability, growth, maturity, and rehabilitation.

Time Is Critical:

If you have received a Nassau County Civil Service disqualification notice:
● Do not wait.
● Do not submit an emotional or rushed appeal.
● Do not exceed the five-page limit.
● Do not miss the 30-day deadline.

For additional information regarding Nassau County Civil Service Disqualification Notices click on the following link:

Appeal of Disqualification-Nassau County

Call Sheerin Law immediately at (631) 239-5825 for a consultation. Your career in civil service is worth protecting.

See why 80+ clients have left 5-star reviews for The Law Office of Kevin P. Sheerin!

Learn More:
Website: www.sheerinlaw.com
Blog: civilservice.sheerinlaw.com
Podcast: www.newyorkcivilservice
lawattorneypodcast.com

-Nassau County Civil Service Disqualification Appeals

80+ Five-Star Google Reviews for the Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin

Mistakes NYPD Candidates Make During The Hiring Process…

Did you fail your NYPD Psychological Evaluation or get disqualified for another reason?

Don’t give up on your dream career! An experienced NYPD appeal lawyer can help you navigate the appeals process and fight for your future.

Contact Kevin Sheerin for a FREE Consultation:
📞 (631) 239-5825
✉️ kevin@sheerinlaw.com

See why 80+ clients have left 5-star reviews for The Law Office of Kevin P. Sheerin!

Learn More:
Website: www.sheerinlaw.com
Blog: civilservice.sheerinlaw.com
Podcast: www.newyorkcivilservice
lawattorneypodcast.com

-Mistakes NYPD Candidates Make During The Hiring Process

80+ Five-Star Google Reviews for the Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin

Your Guide to the NYPD NOPD and NOD Disqualification…

Did you fail your NYPD Psychological Evaluation or get disqualified for another reason?

Don’t give up on your dream career! An experienced NYPD appeal lawyer can help you navigate the appeals process and fight for your future.

Contact Kevin Sheerin for a FREE Consultation:
📞 (631) 239-5825
✉️ kevin@sheerinlaw.com

See why 80+ clients have left 5-star reviews for The Law Office of Kevin P. Sheerin!

Learn More:
Website: www.sheerinlaw.com
Blog: civilservice.sheerinlaw.com
Podcast: www.newyorkcivilservice
lawattorneypodcast.com

-Your Guide to the NYPD NOPD and NOD Disqualification

80+ Five-Star Google Reviews for the Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin

Your Guide to Passing the NYPD Oral Exam…

Did you fail your NYPD Psychological Evaluation or get disqualified for another reason?

Don’t give up on your dream career! An experienced NYPD appeal lawyer can help you navigate the appeals process and fight for your future.

Contact Kevin Sheerin for a FREE Consultation:
📞 (631) 239-5825
✉️ kevin@sheerinlaw.com

See why 80+ clients have left 5-star reviews for The Law Office of Kevin P. Sheerin!

Learn More:
Website: www.sheerinlaw.com
Blog: civilservice.sheerinlaw.com
Podcast: www.newyorkcivilservice
lawattorneypodcast.com

-Your Guide to Passing the NYPD Oral Exam

80+ Five-Star Google Reviews for the Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin

Why Did the NYPD Disqualify Me?

Did you fail your NYPD Psychological Evaluation or get disqualified for another reason?

Don’t give up on your dream career! An experienced NYPD appeal lawyer can help you navigate the appeals process and fight for your future.

Contact Kevin Sheerin for a FREE Consultation:
📞 (631) 239-5825
✉️ kevin@sheerinlaw.com

See why 80+ clients have left 5-star reviews for The Law Office of Kevin P. Sheerin!

Learn More:
Website: www.sheerinlaw.com
Blog: civilservice.sheerinlaw.com
Podcast: www.newyorkcivilservice
lawattorneypodcast.com

-Why Did the NYPD Disqualify Me?

80+ Google Reviews for the  Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin

Why Did I Receive an NYPD Disqualification?

An NYPD candidate can be disqualified from a law enforcement position for a number of reasons, such as:

Psychological issues: Which include anxiety, depression, anger, poor judgment, poor impulse control, poor stress tolerance, poor interpersonal skills and substance misuse, just to name a few.

School records: Candidates can also be disqualified for having an Individual Education Plan (IEP) or having taken ADHD medicine while in school.

Other factors: Racial bias, poor presentation, immaturity, and failure to adjust to adulthood are other factors that can lead to a candidate receiving a disqualification.

The NYPD’s psychological exam is designed to assess a candidate’s emotional and psychological fitness for law enforcement. The exam includes both a written test and an oral interview. The written test consists of questionnaires, symptom inventories, and personality inventory measures, while the oral interview is a one-on-one evaluation with a psychologist.

If you have been disqualified, you can appeal the decision by hiring an independent psychologist to assess you. You may also want to explain that what happened while you were in school is not your current state or condition. In any event, you should take some type of action in order to avoid having the disqualification become final, as this may affect your ability to get any other civil service jobs in the future.

Our firm is led by a retired NYPD Captain with experience in the NYPD Legal Bureau. We have helped numerous candidates successfully appeal their disqualifications over the past 22 years, and we understand the complexities of the process better than anyone.

In addition to offering the industry standards associated with appealing an NYPD Psychological Disqualification, at the Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin, Candidates are offered the option to Reply to their NYPD Disqualification, as we believe Replies can be an effective tool when a Candidate Receives a Notice of Proposed Disqualification (NOPD).

Your Reply will not only list point-by-point responses to the NYPD’s factual and expert assertions, but will also reassert your expert’s findings and offer legal arguments that challenge the sufficiency and validity of the NYPD’s evidence and findings.

Kevin and his experienced legal team have found Replies to be a powerful tool, as rebutting new arguments, clarifying facts and protecting the records can often change the outcome of a Candidate’s disqualification.

Tune in to Kevin’s New York civil service law attorney podcast for further tips, guidance and information about the NYPD Hiring Process. And don’t forget to subscribe and leave a review if you find his episodes helpful.  Remember, stay focused, stay prepared and never give up on your dreams.

Should You Hire an NYPD Disqualification Appeals Attorney

If you failed your NYPD Psychological Evaluation or have been disqualified for any reason and would like to schedule a free consultation, feel free to contact Kevin Sheerin at (631) 239-5825.

Email: kevin@sheerinlaw.com

Website: www.sheerinlaw.com

Blog: civilservice.sheerinlaw.com

Podcast: www.newyorkcivilservicelawattorneypodcast.com

-Why Did I Receive an NYPD Disqualification?

80+ Google Reviews for The Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin

How to Reply to an NYPD Disqualification…

close up photography of smartphone icons

As Appeal Attorneys, we offer Candidates the option to Reply to their NYPD Disqualification, because here, at the Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin, we believe Replies are a very effective tool when a Candidate Receives a Notice of Proposed Disqualification (NOPD).

Kevin has found Replies to be an integral part of a Candidate’s Rebuttal or Appeal Package. Replies often contain relevant letters, psychological/medical reports, supporting evidence, and legal arguments that can have a huge impact on a Candidate’s Disqualification Appeal.

While the NYPD (or DCAS) Answer often contains such things as a summary of their findings, justification for the disqualification, rebuttals to your expert’s conclusions or the NYPD psychologist or investigator’s statements, your Reply can, in turn, provide you with the opportunity to respond to any new issues raised in the NYPD’s Answer. The main purpose of your Reply is to address any new issues that may have been raised and introduce any new evidence or arguments. For example, if the NYPD misrepresented you in their psychological report or made any errors, you Reply can correct the record. Furthermore, a well-crafted Reply will make certain that your arguments are preserved and the record is clear. For instance, if you were erroneously disqualified because the NYPD failed to follow internal guidelines, you can emphasize this fact as well as any others, in your Reply.

At the Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin, your Reply will not only list point-by-point responses to the NYPD’s factual and expert assertions, but will also reassert your expert’s findings and offer legal arguments that challenge the sufficiency and validity of the NYPD’s evidence and findings.

Kevin and his experienced legal team have found Replies to be a powerful tool, as rebutting new arguments, clarifying facts and protecting the records can often change the outcome of a Candidate’s disqualification.

a balance scale on a table

Kevin Sheerin has been a New York Civil Service Law Attorney for more than 22 years. He can assist with your NYPD, FDNY, NYC Department of Sanitation, NYC Department of Corrections or DCAS NYC Department of Citywide Administrative Services  disqualification appeal.

As a retired NYPD Police Captain who specializes in Disqualification Appeals, Kevin has extensive knowledge on how to appeal your Disqualification. Through the years,  Kevin has assisted many clients.

Kevin and his knowledgeable team will go well beyond simply filing your initial appeal. They will proactively counter the NYPD’s justification for your disqualification. Fighting your disqualification is not as simple as offering a straight reply  – it requires the expertise of a skilled attorney who can draft a well-crafted Reply that will not only strengthen your position, but rebut the NYPD’s arguments and maximize your chances of a favorable outcome. Kevin is meticulous and dedicated, and will leave no stone unturned when it comes to preparing a comprehensive Reply. Kevin understands the importance of a comprehensive appeal strategy, which includes a robust Reply to the sustain report. Kevin and his experienced team can walk you through the process, help you find a psychological expert and ensure that you make smart choices along the way.

If you have questions about your NYPD disqualification and would like to schedule a free consultation, feel free to contact Kevin Sheerin at (631) 239-5825.

Email: kevin@sheerinlaw.com

Website: www.sheerinlaw.com

Blog: civilservice.sheerinlaw.com

Podcast: www.newyorkcivilservicelawattorneypodcast.com

-How to Reply to an NYPD Disqualification

🌟 80+ Five-Star Google Reviews for the Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin! 🌟

Can an NYPD Appeal Lawyer Help You?

Did you fail your NYPD Psychological Evaluation or get disqualified for another reason? Don’t give up on your dream career! An experienced NYPD appeal lawyer can help you navigate the appeals process and fight for your future.

Contact Kevin Sheerin for a FREE Consultation:
📞 (631) 239-5825
✉️ kevin@sheerinlaw.com

Learn More:
website: www.sheerinlaw.com
Blog: civilservice.sheerinlaw.com
Podcast: www.newyorkcivilservicelaw
attorneypodcast.com

See why 80+ clients have left 5-star reviews!

-Can an NYPD Appeal Lawyer Help You?

80+ Five-Star Google Reviews for the Law Firm of Kevin P. Sheerin

Factors that can Disqualify an NYPD Candidate…

Did you fail your NYPD Psychological Evaluation or get disqualified for another reason?

Don’t give up on your dream career! An experienced NYPD appeal lawyer can help you navigate the appeals process and fight for your future.

Contact Kevin Sheerin for a FREE Consultation:
📞 (631) 239-5825
✉️ kevin@sheerinlaw.com

See why 80+ clients have left 5-star reviews for The Law Office of Kevin P. Sheerin!

Learn More:
Website: www.sheerinlaw.com
Blog: civilservice.sheerinlaw.com
Podcast: www.newyorkcivilservice
lawattorneypodcast.com

-Factors that can Disqualify an NYPD Candidate