After an ECB hearing 50 West Realty Company LP was fined $500 for changing its building to a use inconsistent with its 1992 CO.  The company filed an Article 78 to appeal.  

An Article 78 filed for a decision after a hearing was held is subject to the standard of "substantial evidence."  That is

 NYC HPD moved to terminate the tenancy benefits of petitioner, Perrett when it was found that  Petitioner’s daughter’s $30,000 income was not reported to the subsidizing authority.  The court found that termination of the tenancy was no so disproportionate  to  the offense in light of all the circumstances as to be shocking to once

 In an article 78 case brought in Kings County New York  Sherwyn Toppin Marketing  Consultants Inc. sued the New York State Liquor Authority (SLA) and requested the Supreme Court reverse the SLA’s  decision canceling their liquor license.

Agents from the State Liquor Authority had issued violations to the bar for permitting consumption of alcoholic