NYC HPD moved to terminate the tenancy benefits of petitioner, Perrett when it was found that  Petitioner’s daughter’s $30,000 income was not reported to the subsidizing authority.  The court found that termination of the tenancy was no so disproportionate  to  the offense in light of all the circumstances as to be shocking to once sense of fairness which is the Article 78 standard of review .  Accordingly the termination of the tenancy was confirmed by the Appellate Division, First Department.